Pitchfork launches new subscription service, introducing reader scores and commenting

Pitchfork has announced a new subscription model that introduces reader scoring and a moderated comments section, marking a major shift in how audiences can engage with the site’s reviews.

Priced at $5 per month, the subscription allows readers to score albums, comment on reviews and access Pitchfork’s full archive of more than 30,000 reviews, while non-subscribers will continue to receive free access to news, features and columns, but have limited access to four free reviews a month, and not be able to comment or score themselves.

View this post on Instagram

In a letter shared on Instagram, editor Mano Sundaresan wrote: “What we’re emphasizing by evolving the site to capture the voices and taste of our readers is that music and music criticism are inherently social.

"The Pitchfork review has always been authoritative... But we publish reviews to turn people onto new music we love (or to save them from music we don't) and create critical discourse. We want our reviews to be generative, and we hope the comments section and other cool new tools on the site will deepen our readers’ connection to music and each other.”

Under the new system, once a review receives more than five reader scores, an aggregate rating will appear beneath Pitchfork’s own score, sitting alongside (rather than replacing) the publication’s editorial verdict. Comments will also be visible below the piece, and will be moderated by Pitchfork editors and governed by newly introduced community guidelines.

Released as a part of the site's 30th anniversary, Pitchfork says the subscription will help fund its ongoing commitment to music criticism, positioning the move as an investment in long-term editorial independence while opening space for wider conversation between critics and readers.

The editorial letter from Mano Sundaresan ends: "You’d be hard-pressed to find a publication today with a more loyal and dedicated following. With your support, we’ve somehow found ourselves at year 30.

"Let’s make it another 30."

Follow us on Instagram, TikTok, Threads, Facebook, and YouTube for the latest music and events content.